Free Will Debate Antony v. Windsor

Working Definition of Free Will for this Debate:

Artwork "Let Him In"
by Pat Marvenko Smith, copyright 1992
God conferred on man the dignity of being able to initiate and control his own actions. He willed that man should be left in the hand of his own counsel, so that he might of his own accord, seek his Creator. Man is rational and therefore like God; he is created with free will and is master over his own acts."

Freedom is the power, rooted in reason and will, to act or not to act, to do this or that, and so to perform deliberate actions on one's own responsibility. By free will one shapes one's own life. Human freedom is a force for growth and maturity in truth and goodness; it attains its perfection when directed toward God, our beatitude.
(CCC #1730-1731).

Affirmative: Scott Windsor
Negative: Micah Antony

Debate Rules/Format:

When a round is posted to this page that is when the "counting" starts for the next round to be posted.
Keep in mind, the questions, "Does man have free will?" and, "When it comes to salvation, does man have any choice in the matter?"

Round 1
2000 words (max) Opening Arguments
Each round...

  • To open with thesis statement
  • Follow by documentation of thesis statement
  • Followed by summary arguments linking documentation with thesis statement
  • Use of valid argumentation throughout
  • All valid sources will have online links.

Round 2a - (within 5 days of start of Round 1)
Up to 300 words Cross-Examination
Participants question each other for clarity (No new material may be introduced, but you may call into question the source or context). This is a question round, not a round to make assertions.

Round 2b - (within 48 hours)
Pariticipants will provide rebuttal of Round 2a of up to 1200 words (new material/sources may be introduced here).

Round 3a - (within 48 hours)
Up to 300 words Cross-Examination of 2b Rebutal (no new material may be introduced again here).

Round 3b - (within 48 hours)
Participants will provide up to 1200 words of rebuttal to Round 3a arguments (new material may be introduced).

Round 4 - (within 72 hours)
Concluding statement up to 1500 words either rebutting opponents argument or reinforcing their own.

Round 5: (Unofficial)
This debate between Free Will and Predestination will continue on BattleACTS (BattleACTS is where the challenge of this debate initiated). A poll will be taken among BattleACTS subscribers (you must be a member of BattleACTS to participate in the poll). This is also being followed on the CathApol Blog.


Windsor's Opening Statement

Antony's Opening Statement


Windsor's Questions to Antony

Antony's Questions to Windsor


Windsor Replies to Antony

Antony Replies to Windsor


Windsor's Questions

Antony's Questions


Windsor's Answers

Antony's Answers


Windsor's Closing Arguments

Antony's Closing Arguments

Back to ACTS Homepage